Site Meter 1P Start » Blog Archive » Could Playing The Wii Compare To Real Exercise?

Could Playing The Wii Compare To Real Exercise?

by Dave Parrack

There is a big debate currently raging over whether Wii Fit, the fitness simulator and computerised exercise trainer already out for the Wii in Japan and Europe, and due out in the U.S. soon, could ever be a viable option for real exercise. That game, combined with the massively popular Wii Sports, means kids can potentially get a wide ranging session of exercise all from the comfort of their own home, and playing their games console.

Greg Chin, a teacher at Archbishop Joseph MacNeil in Edmonton, Vancouver, decided to test the games out to see how much of a good workout they actually gave his class full of junior high school students.

He had them compare real exercise with playing Wii Sports, and came up with some interesting results. While he won’t know the results in full until next week, he has already noted that some of the kids heart rates reached 170 beats per minute, only 10 beats off the 180bpm expected of someone at that age taking part in a proper workout.

He told The Vancouver Sun:

“I was surprised at some of the heart-rate readings. So far, the Wii has been better than I expected.”

While their remains doubters to the cause, there is no doubt in my mind that the Wii, and games such as Wii Sports and Wii Fit could prove a boon for a generation which is lazy and generally do less exercise than the last one.

While it may not be as good as going for a 10 mile run, or a two hour swim, a kid playing a game requiring physical activity on the Wii is going to be doing themselves more good than one who sits down playing PS3 or Xbox 360 all day.

Did You Enjoy this Post? Subscribe to 1P Start. It's Free!

2 Responses to “Could Playing The Wii Compare To Real Exercise?”

  1. Quitting the gym for your Wii - Nintendo Vs. Real Exercise - GAMER.BLORGE.com Says:

    [...] it’s questionable how useful Wii Fit will be for the general population, you have to hand it to Nintendo for at least trying to increase fitness levels. Okay, so they are [...]

  2. 1P Start » Blog Archive » Wii Fit Released In USA - Obesity Experts Unhappy Says:

    [...] by offering $10 gift card to anyone who pre-ordered the game by May 10th. A Teacher in Canada even tested the game out as a possible alternative to more traditional forms of exercise, with surprising [...]

Leave a Reply

Comment moderation is enabled. Your comment may take some time to appear.


About 1P Start

1PStart.com is your ultimate resource in knowing all things gaming. Whatever your choice in console, we're sure to cover it. Along with exciting contests, reviews, previews, trailers and screenshots, 1P Start has got it all! So make sure to hit 1P Start!

1P Start Author(s)
    » Dave-Parrack
    » Paul

Blogging Flair

Join Now Tell Em 1PStart Sent Ya Join Now Tell Em 1PStart Sent Ya

eXTReMe Tracker

Gaming Channel Posts

  • New at the Wii Shop
    There is one new WiiWare game and two Virtual Console games available this week at the Wii Shop. I just bought a Wii SD card to make room as I'm down to around 200 blocks and there are still plenty [...]
  • Microsoft Copies Nintendo
    I really hate when a company tries to copy a novel and popular idea as a means of cashing it. It never works as well and usually is half assed and poorly supported. Case in point, the motion [...]
  • Ghostbusters in Motion
    The latest Ghostbusters: The Video Game trailer is up and man oh man it's getting me all kinds of excited: The game itself better not suck, because this has potential to be the coolest [...]
  • Another look at Nintendo Wii Games
    Here's a look at the few Wii games that are being put in the spotlight at E3 by Nintendo. Transcript to follow the jump. Nintendo holds their E3 press conference and showcases several [...]
  • Nintendo at E3
    It was Nintendo's turn to hold a press conference during E3. Some exciting Nintendo titles for the Wii are announced as well a new accessory for the Wiimote. New game titles that will be [...]
  • SimAnimals
    Want to get up close with wild animals from the comfort of your living room? Then SimAnimals might just be the game you have been looking for. Players use the Wiimote to touch, grab, and [...]
  • Littlest Pet Shop
    The Littlest Pet Shop is another title from the EA Casual Entertainment level and is made possible through a partnership between EA and Hasbro. The Littlest Pet Shop is basically a sim where [...]
  • Rock Band 2's Confirmed Set List at E3 2008
    The wait is finally over and Rock Band fans will rest assured knowing that Rock Band 2's track list is mighty strong. Here's the list, followed by my thoughts: # "Let There Be Rock" by [...]
  • Facebreaker K.O. Party
    EA is bring Facebreaker K.O. Party to the Wii. This boxing game is specifically designed for the unique controls of the Wii. It also promises to be one of the wackiest matches you'll play this [...]
  • Hasbro Family Game Night
    EA Casual Game Entertainment Label is working on bringing classic board games to the Wii. Hasbro Family Game Night features classic games like Yahtzee, Battleship and Connect Four. It also offers new [...]

Hot Off The Press

  • Making the Pyrovile
    This week I went in search of videos as shown on the Official BBC Doctor Who site in conjunction with . You know, the ones that you can't see from outside of the UK, and sometimes from within the UK [...]
  • Sign the Petition Against Madatory Green Lightbulbs
    This post is aimed more for American readers. My apologies to non-American readers. You can go look at Brad Pitt photos here. Anyway, American Migraineurs... A petition to Congress has been [...]
  • Museums and Headaches
    Yesterday, Mom and I went to one of my favorite museums in the world, the Brandywine River Museum at Chadds-Ford, on the Philadelphia Main Line. It's the main museum of the Wyeth family (including [...]
  • Financial support helps reinstate men’s swimming
    Team to compete fully in 2008-09 Arizona State University Vice President for Athletics Lisa Love announced July 15, that the athletic department is fully reinstating the sport of varsity men’s [...]
  • We're Back with 'Heroes' News!
    I have to apologize for my absence as well as the downtime on the site. I'm told that the server issues are fixed and after some brief downtime this week, we should be back for good...and better than [...]
  • EH&S Lab Safety Summit, for anyone working in campus l...
    For anyone working in campus laboratories, registration required 515-294-5359 [...]
  • America Leads Fuji Xerox USA vs. Japan Collegiate Golf Championship; Clanton Picks Up Round One Win
    The United States won three matches and halved another to claim a 7-5 lead after the first round of the 33rd annual Fuji Xerox USA vs. Japan Collegiate Golf Championship at the Tokyo Golf Club. [...]
  • Today Matters ... and So Does the Message on Your Chest
    If you insist on plastering a message across your chest, why not make it a positive one? Tees for Change shirts - and jewelry! - spread positivity, peace, and inspiration. The spring and summer [...]
  • Suri at Union Station
      This little number surprised me as I never thought Katie would put her daughter in an outfit she's already worn. BUT I LOVE this Pucci dress. Isn't it cute on her? Oh and for those of you that [...]
  • The Confederate Crazies
    Alright, I'm gonna stick my neck out here and say that the flap over SC's capitol building, the Rebel flag and the NAACP is totally crazy! Yeah, I know it's a "symbol of the South", [...]